Beard did in fact succeed. Beard won our first NCAA tournament game since Rick Barnes and built an Elite 8 team that won the Big XII Tournament year 2 despite Shaka Smart leaving him a poop sandwich when he arrived.
Here is what we had when Beard showed up:
1. Andrew Jones
2. Brock Cunningham (only player still left in year 2)
3. Courtney Ramey
4. Jase Ferbes
Here is who Beard brought in:
1. Timmy Allen
2. Marcus Carr
3. Dylan Disu
4. Christian Bishop
5. Tyrese Hunter
6. Sir'Jabari Rice
7. Arterio Morris
8. Dillion Mitchel
You know who else Chris Beard brought in and hired?
Rodney Terry. Beard assembled a great enough staff and team that could take over and win if Beard was not there.
Beard absolutely succeeded at making Texas Basketball great again. Beard absolutely left Texas Basketball in a better situation than he found it. To pretend he did not is disingenuous, especially when Beard coached 20% of the season and was responsible for bringing Texas this staff and team. Unfortunately, Beard's time and amount of success was cut short due to an off the court issue. Criticize Beard all you want for his off the court issue, but do not act like he did not succeed here or bring Texas basketball back.
As far as Terry, no one is denying his success or that he did a fantastic job holding the team together and winning following Beard's departure. Even if Terry does not win going forward (and assuming nothing bad happens off the court), I think Terry has forever cemented a positive legacy among fans after what he did this season (not mention his great success as an assistant as well).
It is really annoying that some Texas fans feel other Texas fans are haters or are trying to make some sort of "Beard v. Terry" narrative (by the way, in his press conference, Terry gave Beard a lot of credit and would not agree with pretending Beard does not deserve credit). Both were part of and deserve credit for this team's success. As far as Texas fans go, I have yet to meet a single Texas fan who does not like or support Terry. Not having full confidence in Terry after looking at Terry's heard coaching record does not mean someone is a hater or dislikes Terry. I do not see anyone hating on Terry here, but I do see posters critically evaluating his record and expressing a reasonable view that the odds are against Terry.
It is very clear from history that interim coaches who take over permanently in these situations do not tend to succeed. That said, most thought Texas would not make the Elite 8 following Beard's firing. Terry proved the doubters wrong this year, and I think we all hope he proves the skeptics (including myself) wrong again moving forward! If you are not a doubter, then look forward to Terry proving the skeptics wrong again!
