Best option QB ever?

'63 '69 '70 '05

< 25 Posts
It's the offseason, so cut me some slack... but I was reflecting a bit...

Option football… wishbone or not… is a thing of beauty when it’s run by a team that can do it well. You have to have a tough, durable QB that can make those split second reads… a bruising FB that take a beating all game long whether he has the ball or not (like a Worster or a Leaks) and two HBs that are cat-quick on the outside.

DE stays outside, give it to the FB… you’ll take 3 or 4 every time, right? DE closes down, pull it out and start watching the LB. LB wants to drift out to cover the HB… turn it up inside of him… maybe even make him commit further with a good hard fake pitch before you turn it up. LB takes the QB… pitch it to the HB… and with a lead HB blocking the CB and the SE blocking the Safety… with a little luck you have the defense outnumbered and run for a while.

To think… all those reads happen within split seconds as the play unfolds. However, I realize the offense is dated with the speed of today’s defenses makes it a much more difficult proposition.

One of the best wishbone displays in recent memory came during the high school AAAAA Division I State Finals in 1996 between the Lewisville Farmers and the Judson Rockets. The Farmers won 58-34… and bloodied Judson’s nose like I had never seen it done before… just flat ran over and around the Rockets. It was wishbone perfection with very good reads and fakes… Judson had no answer for it the entire game. If my memory serves me correctly… the Farmers ground game was so effective… they didn’t even attempt a single pass the entire game… it was run, run, run.

So… best option QB ever? Tough question… but…

There’s a reason James Street was called “Slick” Street… as one of the very first wishbone quarterbacks (arguably only the 2nd one behind Bradley) he was a VERY smooth wishbone operator. He wasn’t the fastest… but he could read the option and give it to the man with the best chance of making some yardage almost every time. As I've heard some describe… a magician. I wish some of the young-uns had a chance to see him.

I liked Marty Akins… but for some reason when running the option I remember him calling his own number a little too much… whether something was there or not. Anyone one else remember this?

Also Richard Ritchie at Texas A&I in the mid-70s… he was very good too. Not real big… but a great executioner of the offense… and would remind you of James Street. Gutty, a leader… and just had those “oh-so-hard-to-come-by” intangibles. Geez… those A&I teams of the mid-70’s in NAIA Division I… scary good.

And finally… a name you don't often hear mentioned… but I’m sure will bring a few “oh yeahs” to those that do remember. Mike Washington… QB for Texas Lutheran’s back-to-back NAIA Division II national championship teams in 1974 & 75 while playing for Jim Wacker… and a gentleman that now works in Admissions for UT. Mike Washington was an undersized (5’ 10”, 170 lb) kid from Austin that was cat-quick with an extremely shifty and elusive running style. Much like Vince Young many years later… Mike Washington was a threat to score every time he had the ball. Some may call BS… but I assure you… the man was good. Without Washington… Texas Lutheran… as good as those teams were… would not have won as much as they did.

His junior & senior years they lost only one game… 17-14 to Howard Payne… and… again if memory serves me correctly… that single loss ended what had been a 17 game winning streak carried over from his sophomore and junior years. As far as winning streaks go… A&I was right on TLC’s heels… and quickly eclipsed that mark as part of their very memorable 42 game winning streak from 73 to 77 and national championships in ’74, ’75 & ’76… with the ‘76 team winning games by scores like 77-7, 63-2 and 58-7.

The very center of the small college football universe was located in south Texas in the mid-70’s… and both Washington and Ritchie had a lot to do with that.

Anyway… my $.02.
 
I agree that Frazier is the best, but I'll always have a soft spot in my option heart for the great Air Force QBs during Fisher DeBerry's tenure. Especially Dee Dowis.
 
The first time I saw Vince start a game I said "Oh ****! He is a big tall fast Tommie Frazier!"

Frazier, like Vince, had that immeasurable intangible. The Heart of a Champion.

cow_rose.gif
 
another vote for frazier. the 95 nebraska team was incredible. i'd love to see em matched up against 01 miami, 04 usc or 05 texas.
 
Tommy Frazier was in a class by himself. Dee Dowis was incredible to watch - his quickness and agility were unreal. And James Street was the pioneer of the Wishbone at the big-time level in the late '60s, bringing MNCs home with it. And I'll reluctantly have to recognize the job done by Jack Mildren at ousucks.

HHD
hookem.gif
texasflag.gif
ousucks.gif
 
I was eating breakfast at Flos Cafe & Hill Billy Bar B Q up in Mullin over the holidays and the old timers were watching a bowl game. One of them mentioned when Howard Payne (they love their Howard Payne!) beat Mike Washington & Texas Lutheran in the 70s. I had never heard of that before, or since, until the thread. Weird.
 
Jamelle Holliway was the best pure option wizard I've seen in person but my vote for #1 overall would have to be Turner Gill because he was a pretty good passer as well.
 
If just looking at the University of Texas - Mark McBath was a great wishbone QB - (and the last real wishbone/option QB at Texas). Prior to his ankle injury against OU he was very fast.
 
Honorary Big 8 mentions for:
-- Tuner Gill (NU)
-- J.Holloway (OU)
-- Kordell Stewart (CU) who ran more of a Power I option with 2 TE set....
 
I'd have to say Frazier because he was also a very underrated passer. Tons of TD passes. I don't have his stats in front of me but if I remember right, his completion percentage was only around 50% but his completions per TD was off the charts.

However, those Nebraska teams didn't run as much pure option as people think. Half of what they ran was power sets out of the I-formation. They probably ran pure option about 25% of the time and passed for the remaining 25%.

As for a pure optioneer, I'd have to say Holieway at OU. Very elusive and instinctively knew how to run the triple option. Remember, he was a freshman when OU won the national title.

This topic comes up on this board almost every off season and I've always wondered why Vince Young never gets mentioned. Maybe it's because he didn't operate under center out of an I formation or a wishbone type backfield. However, that zone read was as much option as anything else. It just wasn't a triple option.
 
I'm assuming the OP was referring to option QBs in Texas.

Otherwise, my memory of offseasons past tells me the same thing this offseason is telling us:
1. Frazier
2. Holloway
Others receiving votes
 
And just like every offseason I'll chime in with Beau Morgan as a pure technician of the option offense. He could also pass for their competition level.

Obviously athletically he's behind Frazier and Holloway, but technically he was as good as I've seen.
 
Hate to give props to OU, but Thomas Lott was a badass running the bone in the '70s on the team with Overstreet, Kenny King, et al...and he had the sweet bandana to boot...
 
Have to put Ohio State's Rex Kern in the discussion. Undefeated national champions in 1968. Beat USC's OJ Simpson in the Rose Bowl. 20-game win streak in 68-69 in his soph and jr. years.Rex Kern
 
Tommie Frazier highlight reel:The Link

The highlights are primarily his TD passes but notice that most of those passes were off option play action because teams respected his ability to run it well.

The most impressive aspect about Frazier may be the fact that he was the only QB under Osborne ever to grasp 100% of the playbook according to the former coach. TF audibled nearly every play based on his reading of the defense. The power runs, options and passes were largely predicated on TF's reads.

As for pure option greatness I also have an immense amount of respect for OU's Hollieway. In a lot of ways Frazier was simply a slight upgrade to Jamielle.

Beau Morgan certainly maximized his talent.
 
Frazier was good, but let me throw a thought in.

When Marty Akins ran it, there were lots of teams running it and people actually had defenses against it.

When Frazier ran it, hardly anyone was running it and defenses only a week to really prepare.

That gives Frazier an edge.
 

Recent Threads

Back
Top