Shiner, I was making what has turned out to be an unfruitful effort to help people understand what a communist is. I'm not arguing for the US to become a social democracy. I'm just trying to educate folks who apparantly want to revise the definition of Communist into something very different than what academics understand it to be. I was hoping against hope the "West Germany, East Germany" thing might trigger some flashback to high school civics that would let you know they had very different sorts of government. (Hint, a lot of freedom loving people in East Germany really would have preferred to live in West Germany, so much so that the communists built a wall to keep them in. Ronald Reagan didn't say "Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall." so that Germany would become a unified communist country.)
Maybe Allen West is a smart good guy and it's just by chance that every time I notice him he's saying something at odds with what seems true and logical. Shiner, I do think you need to be open to the possibility that perhaps it's a factor other than genius that causes people to see things the way you do.
Deez -- your insights are helpful and I agree that Communist despots and Monarchist despots have much in common. I always wish to live in the area where human rights are protected and people have power over their government. Again, I see politicians in our capitalist country mostly fall within a very narrow range of political beliefs compared with those in other industrialized countries. We have capitalists with left-leaning tendencies and we have those who want little restraint on business.
By the way, when I was studying these things it seems like you had the Nazis/Divine Rights Monarchists on the right and the totalitarian communists on the left. Your model, with anarchy on the right and absolute despotism on the left seems more useful. It's not the way I learned it, but it makes a lot of sense. Would the polar opposites under you model, be say, Somalia, with no effective government, and North Korea with over the top oppression?