Great post. I have spent a couple of hours already on it, and haven't seen many of the film clips yet.
Agree this is the greatest game ever, and the reasons are clearly stated at the top of the thread.
I attended the 1969 Texas-Arkansas game, and in some ways these two games were very similar, but coming in the Rose Bowl as the national championship game, and the sheer volume of great players on each team, so many of whom have gone on to be professional stars already, makes this game unique.
Even beyond those facts, the most amazing feature of the 2006 Rose Bowl was the huge number of great plays-plays where a professional quality receiver made a great catch, covered well by a professional quality db, a pass thrown so well by a great qb that it was complete even though great defense was played-over and over, this happened on so many plays in that game. Just incredible, jaw-dropping offensive line play by USC, these things elevate this game to the top of any such discussion.
Show me a game with that much talent on both sides, where that many great plays were made, where there were two very notable win streaks on the line, for the national championship, with that much hype, decided on a miracle play in the last minute, and set in the bowl that is the best by far for setting, atmosphere and tradition-some games have one or more of these features, but none have them all.
This was the greatest college game of all time.