So interesting story. The orthopedist I saw yesterday was very nice and appeared competent, but gave the option of surgery or not as I described above. The doctor I really wanted to see was a foot and ankle specialist in the same practice who has done surgery on my wife's foot and two other members of the family, however his schedule was booked up though so I went with Doc #1. After that visit I really wanted to talk to Doc #2 so called and earliest he could see me was early next week.
Fast forward to this morning when my mother was in his office for a pre-op visit and as they were chatting at the end she mentioned I was coming to see him next week. He asked what for and she told him the story. She said he got very serious all of a sudden and pulled the records from his peer, Doc #1. He said he didn't to wait that long and asked his staff to call and get me in tomorrow, with pending schedule for surgery Monday or Tuesday of next week. The no surgery option felt "iffy" to me after research and talking to several friends and family members who have gone through a ruptured Achilles in the past, and the fact Doc #2, who we've had significant wonderful experience with and trust as a result, dialed up the urgency and is thinking surgery before we speak makes me more confident that's the right choice. It's where I was leaning already and we will see how it goes tomorrow when we meet, but my guess is I'll be saying "cut me Mick" next week.
By the way, on a HF Board related note, Doc #2 will remain nameless but I'll give you an easy hint - he was the kicker for Mack in the early years. I would be the fourth family member he's performed surgery on in the last two years so I'm looking for a family discount...