I have noticed the media keeps comparing Georgia losing to Texas in the Sugar Bowl to Alabama losing to Utah in the Sugar Bowl in 2008.
I think it would be a good time to analyze that Alabama team and this Texas team:
2004 Alabama 6-6 lost Music City Bowl
2005 Alabama 10-2 won Cotton Bowl
2006 Alabama 6-7 lost Independence Bowl
2007 Alabama 7-6 won Independence Bowl
2008 Alabama 12-2 lost Sugar Bowl
2014 Texas 6-7 lost Texas Bowl
2015 Texas 5-7 no bowl
2016 Texas 5-7 no bowl
2017 Texas 7-6 won Texas Bowl
2018 Texas 10-4 won Sugar Bowl
So no one on the 2008 Alabama team had been to a BCS bowl before. Some seniors may have been to the Cotton Bowl when it was not a BCS bowl. However, for the most part, the 2008 Alabama squad had endured 6-7 loss seasons and trips to Shreveport. That team was in no way accustomed to playing for national titles and had a similar background to the 2018 Texas team. 2016 Texas lost to Kansas. 2007 Alabama lost to UL Monroe. There is no reason on earth the 2008 Alabama team would have been unmotivated as this was the biggest bowl game anyone on the team had played in. The year before an 11-2 Georgia was able to find motivation to beat Hawaii in the Sugar Bowl 41-10.
What really happened to the 2008 Alabama team in the Sugar Bowl? An underrated team who no one gave a shot led by a former Urban Meyer disciple out-played and out-coached a good Alabama team that had Kirby Smart running the defense. Utah was the better team. 2008 Alabama was overrated.
What really happened to the 2018 Georgia team in the Sugar Bowl? An underrated team who no one gave a shot led by a former Urban Meyer disciple out-played and out-coached a good Georgia team that had Kirby Smart running the defense. Texas was the better team. 2018 Georgia was overrated.
As further a reference, an underrated Ohio State team who no one gave a shot led by Urban Meyer with Tom Herman calling plays out-played and out-coached the good 2014 Alabama team that had Kirby Smart running the defense in the Sugar Bowl. Ohio State was the better team. 2014 Alabama was overrated.
2018 Texas’s players and coaches improved as the year went along and were underrated. 2018 Georgia’s players and coaches were overrated. Texas was the better team when it played Georgia in the Sugar Bowl. Motivation has nothing to do with it.