Y'know, Ed, I was just looking @ my Wolvie's tonight when we got home from the rodeo... the heel cap on the R boot is coming un stitched.
Then I looked @ the L boot & it's got about a 1-1/2" split in the leather that matches the heel cap.
I need to go to the Wolverine website & see if they have any kind of warranty on that sort of thing. I got them for Xmas '06, so it's not like they are THAT old... granted, I wear them daily... but still, the tread isn't even totally worn through.
Just ordered a new pair of Georgia boots off the net to replace a pair that I wore nearly every day for at least four years. Mine were neither laceup nor waterproof, but I will vouch for their quality. Wore the leather out, but the synthetic nonskid soles had years of wear left. Best price on the 'net was $99. Since I paid $125 in a store years ago, I would call that reasonable.
It's according to how much you want to spend and how much you will wear the boots.
I have a pair of steel toe Wolverines with shock absorbing soles that I wear when working at ranch and they are great. They are not lace ups so some of the heel support busted but it doesn't cause blisters or cause discomfort. I would recommend them. I also like the comfort of the Dr. Martens but it's been awhile since I tried their work boots.
I probably have a rougher line of work for shoes than 95% of people here, and I swear by Redwing laceups. I go through a pair every 18 months or so, where Wolverines were lasting ~6 months. Redwings run me about $130, the Wolverines about half that last I looked. Twice the price, but they last me over twice as long, so the economics work out.
Granted, you won't be caving, blowing **** up, jackhammering, pouring concrete, running electrical, welding, or walking through water 200' underground in your backyard in all likelihood. I'll bet that the Wolverines would do you just fine.
For a lace up, waterproof, non-steel toe work boot it is hard to go wrong with Red Wings. I have had good experience with Chippewa, Georgia and Danner lace ups as well. I have had Wolverine, Rocky and Dan Post boots fall apart on me before so I can't recommend them. Wolverine's customer service is pretty good, but Rocky and Dan Post seem to go out of their way to avoid doing the right thing.
If there is a Cavender's in your area, they are selling off the current stock of Carhartt work boots for $59. They are manufactured by Red Wing for Carhartt and retail for about twice that. I can't vouch for the lace-ups but the pull on wedge sole models are top notch.
When I was working in a position that required safety shoes, the Red Wings worked great. Can't say I've used them recently - that was back in '93 last time I needed steel toed shoes. Since then, the Wolverine hikers seem at least as good as any others I've found.
I wear my steel toe Red Wing 4470s when chain sawing and such. Love em. Did the soak in a bathtub breaking in method and they are great. And mesquite thorn proof, which is crucial for me.