which Upton is the better prospect

[Ramathorn]

And are their games really similar?

 

[hookem2003]

If I had a pick, it's Justin. BJ is one hell of a player, but he's not a natural CF. His numbers are very nice, but his batting average last year was the result of an abnormal amount of batted balls falling in for hits.

Justin was the unanimous #1 pick of his draft, has essentially been the #1 prospect ever since, and is now proving to be a phenom. His upside is Griffey-esque.