TX Schools multimillion dollar food watch

general35

5,000+ Posts
Smile, Texas schoolchildren. You're on calorie camera.

That's the idea behind a $2 million project being unveiled Wednesday in the lunchroom of a San Antonio elementary school, where high-tech cameras installed in the cafeteria will begin photographing what foods children pile onto their trays — and later capture what they don't finish eating.

Digital imaging analysis of the snapshots will then calculate how many calories each student scarfed down. Local health officials said the program, funded by a U.S. Department of Agriculture grant, is the first of its kind in a U.S. school, and will be so precise that the technology can identify a half-eaten pear left on a lunch tray.

"This is very sophisticated," said Dr. Roberto Trevino, director of the San Antonio-based Social & Health Research Center, which will oversee the program.

Parents will be required to give consent for their children to participate, and receive regular reports showing what foods their kids are filling up on at lunch. Trevino said only the trays, and not students, will be photographed.

Here's how it works: students are assigned lunch trays with a unique bar code. After the children load up their plates down the line — mashed potatoes or green beans? french fries or fruit? — a camera above the cashier takes a picture of each tray.

When lunch is over and the kids return their plates to the kitchen, another camera takes a snapshot of what's left on the tray. Software then analyzes the before and after photos to calculate calories consumed and, according to Trevino, a report of nutrients in the foods.
__________________________________________________

I have a question. Why not spend the money on just healthy food. If the kids want to eat french fries or mashed potatoes, make them bring them from home. I'm sure taking money away from the crap food would make available more funds for the good food. Further, why can't they simply do an analysis based upon the inventory and what foods are consumed? Wouldnt this be easier to determine? They could then have a statistical analysis done. Also, why dont the schools concentrate on actual education? This appears to be a huge waste of money but that isnt surprising at all.
 
Childhood obesity is an enormous problem. Good information costs money. I'm no researcher, but I've worked with some market researchers and the right kind of information can fuel and ideas and market insight worth a lot more than $2 million. I gotta tell you that if this were my information to find, Food choice is pretty complicated and like a lot of decision-making is not necessarily powered by logic and deep thought.
 
"Good information costs money"

How much money does it cost to know not to feed too much carb laden and fried food? is there anyone over 10 who knows if you eat cheeseburgers fries and coke everyday you will get fat?


what happened to common sense?

Why do we ALWAYS jump right to " it is the gov't responsibility to monitor what kids eat" so Hey let's come up with a new expensive program?
general makes a good common sense suggestion. don't offer bad food at schools. Since most kids eat 2.5 meals at school even if they eat a carb laden meal at night one meal won't turn them into obese kids.

This is just stupid. Of couse this does call into the question of who all the starving kids are if so many are obese.
 
I'll agree we all have easy access to information that would drive intelligent food choice. However in too many cases we are not making good food choices. If this is a simple problem to solve, why are Americans, on average, too fat?
I don't know enough to defend this specific project. If I were trying to find this information I'd do some brainstorming and experimentation before I rolled out a monstorous research project like this. Maybe somebody already has. If so, I hope they have a network of of subscribers to help fund this project who could profitably apply the information.
 
Such a typical government response. It is funny, I have Russians that work for me and even they know about our government waste. They say that the US space program spent millions of dollars to engineer a ball point pen that will work in the no gravity environment of space. The Russian space program uses pencils.
 
The answer is to only offer healthy choices to the kids in school. They will adapt. They're much better at adaptation than adults.
 
gee I wonder what the results will be....hummm so glad we have this food watch to connect the dots.
rolleyes.gif
 
If this is a simple problem to solve, why are Americans, on average, too fat?
__________________________________________________

It's not very complicated. every body is different but basically, you have a certain daily calorie intake that will maintain your weight at a certain level. depending on the person, this will range from 1850-2500 calories per day. your body will be able to absorb more calories if you exercise a lot. an extra 3500 calories per week over this amount will raise your weight about 1 pound. Eating a high carb/sugar diet will slow your metabolism which may add on more additional weight. Americans eat too much high carb/processed food and eat too much and dont get enough exercise. This is why we are fat. it is disturbing that kids are so fat because they are supposed to have high metabolisms. they have slowed because kids do not play and are not active as we were when we were younger. i could eat an obscene abount of food as a teen and not gain a pound.

for adults, take a so-called "healthy lunch" of a turkey sandwhich on wheat, no cheese, chips and a coke. The sandwhich is about 350 calories, add mayonaise and its about 550, small portion of chips about 220 and a coke another 240. That is 1010 calories. What if you get an egg mcmuffin and a coffee for breakfast, no sugar, not too bad, 325 calories(excluding high sodium, carb and fat content (1335 total calories for day). For dinner, we are going to have a taco salad. Going to go with shreded beef, cheese, guacamole, salsa, pico, black beans, a few chip strips, etc. (note I am skipping a dressing) 750 calories. So, right now we are a little under 2100 calories. Right now, a person that does not exercise, he is at his break even point, perhaps a little over. any other caloric intake will result in weight gain. if i had put on a jalapeno ranch dressing, an extra 500 calories, chips in hot sauce (lets not go there), a beer, 100-300, an extra soda, 250, an extra small bag of chips, 250. I believe that high carb/processed foods, slow your metabolism even more. all you need is an extra 500 calories per day and by the end of the week, its 3500=1 lb of weight gain. in 20 weeks, thats 20lbs. so you see, its not that difficult to gain weight. now, obviously there are variables but the point it, diet and exercise are everything. schools are education centers, they should be teaching kids about health. allowing them to eat tater tots and pizza at lunch doesnt teach them a thing. i brought my lunch as a kid every day anyway. i always thought the cafeteria food was gross as did most of my friends.
 
Limit their choices; healthier foods, smaller portions. They probably get enough calorie-heavy/sat fat/sugarful junk food at home.

I don't miss the "mystery meat" patties with "mystery" gravy they served at school, but I do miss the Frito pies would could get in jr high: a small bag of chips w/ a slit cut on the side and a ladle-full of Wolf Brand chili poured in, and a plastic spoon. Making them now at home isn't the same.

We didn't get fat from 'em, but they weren't very good for the complexion.
 
The choices at school suck and you don't need cameras to know the kids eat the hot dogs, chips and chocalate milk and leave the carrots and applesauce to throw away. What do expect a kid to do when presented with that choice and no one at the table to guide them on what to eat?

What a waste.
 
in regards to food choice, the schools have become bad parents, what the kids want, the kids get. you pretty much have to speak to someone over 70 to get decent common sense advice nowadays....yeah, lets spend 2 million bucks to take pictures and see if the kids that eat a lot of the fat fillled processed foods are fat...geez...i know what my grandmother would say about this.
 
I can tell them a really inexpensive way to find out which kids are getting too much sugar.
 

NEW: Pro Sports Forums

Cowboys, Texans, Rangers, Astros, Mavs, Rockets, etc. Pro Longhorns. The Chiefs and that Swift gal. This is the place.

Pro Sports Forums

Recent Threads

Back
Top