Texas Redistricting in Hands of the Courts

Satchel

2,500+ Posts
and that's as it should be:

Texas Redistricting Map Going to Federal Trial

By Shira Toeplitz
Roll Call Staff


The Texas Congressional map is headed to trial, ensuring a federal court in San Antonio will redraw House district boundaries for the 2012 primaries.

The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ruled against the Lone Star State’s request for a summary judgment Tuesday, delivering a decisive blow to Texas Republicans hoping for swift approval.

A federal three-judge panel wrote Texas “used an improper standard or methodology” to determine minority representation in their redraw, and “there are material issues of fact in dispute that prevent this Court from entering declaratory judgment” on if the map adheres to the Voting Rights Act.

Texas is one of several states that requires preclearance from the Department of Justice before making any changes to its voting laws, including its new Congressional maps. But instead of asking the Justice Department to approve their new map, Texas officials went straight to federal court last summer — a decision that has prolonged the process.

Anticipating lengthy legal proceedings, a federal court in San Antonio already began to draw temporary maps for the 2012 primaries. House candidates must file by early December for the scheduled March primary.

Explosive population growth in Texas caused the state to pick up four new House seats in reapportionment. Texas Republicans drew, and Gov. Rick Perry (R) signed, an aggressive new Congressional map that solidified many of their recent gains, plus included a few new GOP dominant districts.

Most of the state’s population increase came from the Hispanic community. The Justice Department argues that Texas mapmakers disregarded this in their redraw, even dialing back minority voting power under the passed map.
[email protected] | @shiratoeplitz
 
Maybe they should do like Houston did and create a district that is 70+ Hispanic however only 15% (or so) of the registered voters are Hispanic.

Personally I find this whole gerrymandering thing repulsive and arrogant from all of our politicians.
 
I live in a minority majority district and I have not noticed that my longtime hispanic congressman voted any different on anything than your average anglo would. He really sucked and got beat by a republican who is even more stupid than he was. He doesn't vote much different from the democrat but he does cry about the deficit a little more before voting to continue farm subsidies.

The republicans in the legislature knew or should have known this was going to happen but they blithely ignored it and wrote districts they knew would get us in to federal court. Thanks, ********.
 
Both parties in Texas are notorious overreachers when it comes to redistricting. One reason they overreach is that they know the maps they draw are going to court (for constitutional or Voting Rights Act reasons), no matter what they do. Accordingly, the majority party screws the minority party as hard as it can, and once the federal court gets involved and screws the party that drew the map, you hope to end up with one that's fair.

I'm not defending the GOP here. They're terrible "gerrymanderers" like the Democrats were in 1991, but there will always be a court battle. The could have given the Democrats a majority of the seats in the delegation, and they still would have gotten sued.

The real tragedy is that the fight is always partisan. Democrats are always pissed because there aren't enough minority districts (meaning Democratic districts). Republicans always want the opposite. Nobody is pissed that neither party draws competitive districts in which the general elections actually matter, and that's where the real outrage should lie
 
I wonder how many states do not have their redistricting plans evaluated either by the DOJ? or a district court.

I still think it was a smart move by Texas to send the plans directly to United States district court in DC even knowing it will head to trial.
That is still better than letting Holder and DOJ make the decision
 
Let a computer make the map based strictly on head count. Anything else is just so much BS. The courts will screw it up worse than any legislature.
 
huis
I think this is an important point, " I have not noticed that my longtime hispanic congressman voted any different on anything than your average anglo would."

Obviously your ' hispance congressman" was not a wise latina.
biggrin.gif


BTW I am sure the converse is true as well.
 

NEW: Pro Sports Forums

Cowboys, Texans, Rangers, Astros, Mavs, Rockets, etc. Pro Longhorns. The Chiefs and that Swift gal. This is the place.

Pro Sports Forums

Recent Threads

Back
Top