For me personally, I don't believe people (usually overly idealistic / romantic vegetarian types) when they try to tell me that the Indians lived in such perfect harmony with nature that they always killed their game in such a way that it never suffered.
********. For starters, the Indians had few if any means at their disposal to dispatch a quick death to game animal.. especially a large one. Bows, spears, axes and traps all mean a not-so-instant death. Besides, If the difference between starvation and your family getting a life-sustaining high protein meal is a mile long chase across the prairie with you shooting arrow after arrow into an already gut shot Buffalo then that is sure as **** what you are going to do. If the difference between life and death for you and your people is a rabbit that suffers in your snare all night long with a broken leg, you are going to set that snare and eat that rabbit.
It's admirable to want to eliminate the suffering of food animals but it's also mindset you can only afford in a time of plenty. Indians lived much closer to hardship than we do and for that reason I think they did whatever they had to survive.
********. For starters, the Indians had few if any means at their disposal to dispatch a quick death to game animal.. especially a large one. Bows, spears, axes and traps all mean a not-so-instant death. Besides, If the difference between starvation and your family getting a life-sustaining high protein meal is a mile long chase across the prairie with you shooting arrow after arrow into an already gut shot Buffalo then that is sure as **** what you are going to do. If the difference between life and death for you and your people is a rabbit that suffers in your snare all night long with a broken leg, you are going to set that snare and eat that rabbit.
It's admirable to want to eliminate the suffering of food animals but it's also mindset you can only afford in a time of plenty. Indians lived much closer to hardship than we do and for that reason I think they did whatever they had to survive.