Saw 'True Confessions'.......

FAST FRED

500+ Posts
......a crime drama from 1981, starring Robert De Niro and Robert Duvall, and thought it was really good.

The Link

I don't know how this movie escaped my cinematic attention, but I found it on NETFLIX and I'm glad I did.

It has little action, beyond investigative police work, and depends largely on character development to move its storyline along.

But I think that it's very worthwhile as a rental for a fan of moviemaking or these actors if you've missed it too.

smile.gif


The vibe pleasingly reminded me of "Chinatown" or "LA Confidential" or even "The Godfather" and I mean those comparisons as high praise.

The detailed attention this flick has for the setting in 1940's Los Angeles and interesting police procedure, plus the fine work of the leading and character actors really put this one over the top for me.

It seems to be based loosely on the famous, yet still unresolved, Black Dahlia murder case.

Don't expect car chases, gunplay, action-filled excitement or a big ending, but rather fine acting of a realistic, gritty screenplay with much attention paid to detail and style.

In fact, I don't know that I've ever seen a better adaptation of what must have been a good crime novel into a good crime movie.

In fact, since I've never read the novel, how good an adaptation this movie is isn't even something I can say with any authority.

So, in fact, I didn't actually say that if you read my wording two sentences above correctly.

smile.gif


"Zodiac" fell a little short for me, but only because I thought it was way too long.

"Hollywoodland" was just OK, I felt it's screenplay and/or direction held it back.

And the recent movie entitled "The Black Dahlia" was less informative and compelling than I had hoped it would be.

I hope all my praise for "True Confessions" will not raise your expectations unreasonably high, because I rented it expecting little and was pleasantly surprised partly because of exactly that initial mindset.

I also strongly and I hope helpfully suggest you watch it with the subtitles turned on, because I believe the 1940's slang, police language and other important dialog will too often be hard to catch and/or understand without your seeing the words.

I noticed that the subtitles were very helpful to me.

Actually, I thought watching this film (with the subtitles on) was much like reading good, rich, pithy and interesting descriptions and dialog from a book, without ever needing to visualize the characters in my mind (since it was so well cast and acted and the pictures were already moving).

I enjoyed it a lot; if you've seen it or give it a try, let us know what you think.

smile.gif
 
The movie kind of went under the radar when it was released as well. In some ways, it's like LA Confidential where the plot is secondary and sometimes obscure.

It's definitely worth watching for the excellent contrast between the brothers played by DeNiro and Duval. The difficulty of the plot is never, to my memory, ever really cleared up. At the end of LA Confidential, you have a couple of sequences that make the conflict clearer. True Confessions, as I recall, never quite makes it there.

Or maybe I was too young and dumb to get it. Never know.
 
True Confessions never tries to solve the ambiguity because its point was that life is ambiguity. Superb film.
 
We agree, RomaVicta and huisache.

Thanks for your comments.

smile.gif


As I mentioned, I really think I got much more out of this movie because I had the subtitles turned on.

Fully understanding all that was said really helped complete the vibe and the character driven storyline.

Reading the dialog was like reading a good book that had moving pictures.

I can say that I've only rarely experienced that feeling from a movie before.

In fact, that makes twice now that I've said it.

smile.gif


"A Man For All Seasons" is another such character/dialog-driven flick that comes to mind.

cool.gif
 
The novelist who wrote True Confessions died a few years ago and his wife, Joan Didion, wrote an interesting memoir about her loss. He was John Gregory Dunne and was a writer who spent a lot of time trying to provoke thought with his novels. His wife writes the cleanest prose of any non fiction person around. I never cared much for her novels but her other stuff is great. And I don't mean real good, but great.

Her book The White Album is still in print after thirty years and her first collection, Slouching Towards Bethlehem, is also a classic.

I recommend both her and him to anybody who likes to read thoughtful pieces.

This movie is one of the few that does justice to a very good book.
 

Weekly Prediction Contest

* Predict HORNS-AGGIES *
Sat, Nov 30 • 6:30 PM on ABC

Recent Threads

Back
Top