Saw 'American Sniper'......

FAST FRED

500+ Posts
,,,,,,,,,starring Bradley Cooper and directed by Clint Eastwood.

The Link

My wife and I joined an almost full house of 250 or so viewers at our local multi-plex at 2:00 last Friday afternoon.

Reportedly, several showings during the previous week turned away a number of expectant movie goers and I've noticed that six starting times are scheduled daily at least through the next weekend.

Our audience seemed very interested and remained quite attentive with frequent hushed murmurs, sudden gasps and other quiet sounds indicating apprehension, shock and/or empathy as Bradley Cooper portrayed Navy Seal Chris Kyle growing up with his Texas family, meeting and marrying his wife, serving with his comrades in arms in Iraq and trying to adjust to his life back home after each of his four tours.

The only thing that didn't seem real and true to me in this entire film was a single doll held by new father Kyle which fell noticeably short of being an actual baby.

Cooper gives a believable, well studied and thoughtful, objective and nuanced, cinematic portrait of a soldier serving his country and doing his specific duty to protect his brothers in arms from those trying to do them harm.

Kyle was skillful, sensitive to the responsibilities of his mission, used good judgement in the field and was brave.

Clint Eastwood delivers an accurate and balanced film about the harsh brutality of war and the different realities of returning home.

I appreciated this flick much as I do "Sergeant York," with Gary Cooper, and "We Were Soldiers," featuring Mel Gibson.

Each of those excellent motion pictures gives a vivid and honest representation of war, both on the field of battle and on the home front.

Thanks to all those (and their families) who have served, over there and over here.

IMO, Chris Kyle and his comrades are American heroes.

And I was proud that the audience at my theater in Marble Falls paid such close attention and when many clapped before filing out.

smile.gif


In my review of "Unbroken" I noted how the incomplete denouement and the lack of enough visual resolution of that true, heroic story disappointed me at movie's end.

I'll look forward to seeing new director Angelina Jolie's work improve in the future.

Here, in comparison, I thought seasoned and more practiced director Eastwood got it right.

smile.gif


What did you think?
 
I enjoyed American Sniper partly as a Veteran of this era and also as a fan of good movies. I saw it at the Alamo Drafthouse so having some great food to nom on made it even better.
 
I saw Sniper today...I had neither high nor low expectations going in, as I had read both enthusiastic and "meh" reviews.

Put me in the enthusiastic camp: This may be Clint's best directorial effort ever. Can't believe he did not get a nomination, but maybe the competition this year is just too fierce (have yet to see any of the other Oscar nominated films). Glad that Cooper got an Oscar nod; amazing how much he bulked up for the role. Definitely not the Coop we knew from The Hangover.

Like Fred said, the only misstep was the "fake baby."

Maybe I'll think differently this time next year, but IMO this film is right up there with Saving Private Ryan
as the best war film ever.

One last thing: in no way does this film glorify war, as apparently some left-wing types have carped.
 
Loved it! Funny, I didn't notice the fake baby but that's the first thing my daughter and wife talked about afterward.

Theater was dead silent for a minute or two after.
 
I thought it was a good movie but not great. There is alot to the story that wasn't told or not told well. I don't consider this on the same planet in terms of war movies like Saving Private Ryan. However the real story of Chris Kyle is a great one and a real American hero.
 
What I want to really know is how does a rodeo cowboy who grew up in Texas become such a good swimmer to go thru SEALS training. These guys are in the water every day swimming in the ocean. I wonder if this is in the book? I've been scratching my head on this. lol
 
I'm a little older than Kyle was, but I remember working cattle or hauling hay, then going swimming in the creek or the pond we called "the stock tank." It happens all over rural Texas
 
This post was made just before going to the new 2015 platform. Post as normal after it if you wish.

HornHuskerDad
(5000+ posts)
02/15/15 08:46 PM
Re: Saw

Mrs. HHD was a bit reluctant to see it, but I persuaded her to go with me. And she left the theater impressed with the movie (as I did). Recommend it to all - it's a great portrayal of the realities of military service.

HHD
hookem.gif
texasflag.gif
coolnana.gif
ousucksnana.gif
 
What I want to really know is how does a rodeo cowboy who grew up in Texas become such a good swimmer to go thru SEALS training. These guys are in the water every day swimming in the ocean. I wonder if this is in the book? I've been scratching my head on this. lol
Probably most enter boot camp as average swimmers. How do naval aviators learn how to land a jet fighter on the deck of a carrier? Plenty of kids that grow up out in the country learn how to swim. Some even have their own pools :texasflag:
 
I thought it was outstanding. Took my 2 sons 22 & 20 a couple of weeks ago and talked to them about the horrors of war. I came very close to being drafted for duty in Vietnam.

One person got up and left when Kyle left his home to go to the shooting range with the crazy vet he was going to help.

Tears in my eyes watching his funeral. An American Hero.

absolute silence when we left the theatre.
 
Last edited:
Pretty large crowd when I saw it. Only movie I've seen where no one said a word as they were leaving the theater.
 

Weekly Prediction Contest

* Predict HORNS-AGGIES *
Sat, Nov 30 • 6:30 PM on ABC

Recent Threads

Back
Top