Here's my first brisket

chuychanga

500+ Posts
Got my first smoker for Father's Day and used it to make a feast for myself and the other dad's in my family on Saturday. Here's the report:

Picked up my brand new Weber Smokey Mountain on Friday afternoon and put it to use that same night. The Virtual Weber Bullet website says no seasoning required since it's lined with porcelain. So I just put that sucker together and let her rip.

Got an 11 lb packer at HEB. I trimmed a good amount of fat, but left the fat cap at about a 1/4 inch thick and left everything between the point and flat. I'll take my lumps now. It was too late by the time I read the "Fat Cap" thread. Next time I do one I'll leave all the fat on just to see the difference, but this one turned out great.

I rubbed it with Stubb's rub the day prior.

I followed the virtual Weber site's advice and used the minion method of fire starting with a full load of unlit Kingsford, topped off with about 20 lit briquettes and about 6 fist sized chunks of pecan (I was going to use oak, but could only find it in chips, not chunks.)

The temp got right up to 200 in no time flat. I closed it up a little and had it dialed in at about 230 fairly easily. I stayed up for about an hour watching it because I was paranoid, this being my first time and all. Meat went on at 3:15am. I finally went back to bed a little after 4:00. Got up at 5:50 and it was still steady at 232 degress. Went back to bed. Got up at 7:00 and that sucker had shot up to 265. I'm not sure how long it had been there, but certainly less than an hour, so no sweat.

I closed it all up on the bottom and it still kept climbing to a peak of 275. So finally I opened up the door and started removing about a third of the hot coals. That finally brought it back down. I kept it at about 210 for the next few hours with no problems. Next time I'll start with less charcoal.

Left the house at 9:00am for my son's swim lesson. Temp was 216. Got home two hours later and it was 219. Throughout the afternoon I rarely touched the vents again and it stayed pegged between 220 and 240. I did throw on a few more chunks of wood to keep the smoke churning. Brisket came off about noon-thirty. Internal temp was 165. Wrapped it and put in the oven at 225. Took about and hour and a half to get it to 190 internal. Then kept it wrapped and stuck it in the cooler until dinner time.

I also did a rack and a half of pork spare ribs, following Hornian's method to a T. Timed everything to be rested and ready at 5:00pm for dinner with my dad, my wife's dad, and all the associated family members. All meat was out, unwrapped and resting for about 35 minutes prior to slicing.

Here we go.
Smokingmyfirstbrisket011.jpg


Before trimming.
Smokingmyfirstbrisket012.jpg


After trimming.
Smokingmyfirstbrisket014.jpg


Opening my new toy.
Smokingmyfirstbrisket020.jpg


Thar she blows.
Smokingmyfirstbrisket002.jpg


Dialed in.
Smokingmyfirstbrisket003.jpg


Fast forward about 13 hours... and viola...
Smokingmyfirstbrisket007.jpg

Smokingmyfirstbrisket009.jpg

Smokingmyfirstbrisket008.jpg


Post-rest
Smokingmyfirstbrisket004.jpg

Smokingmyfirstbrisket005.jpg


It was moist. It was tender. The rib bones were falling out of the meat. I didn't get a smoke ring, I guess because I wrapped toward the end, but they were chock-full of smoky taste. All in all I am very happy with how it all turned out. We ate it all with some twice baked potatoes and baked beans. Yummy.

Next time I'll try it without trimming any fat before cooking, like I said, this round came out nice.

Happy Father's Day everybody and thanks for all the BBQ threads for info and advice!

edited to fix the pics
 
Fantastic! We are proud of you. But damn, you are sure younger and smaller than I pictured you being. The internet is weird that way. We just assume somebody is all grows up.
 
That boy is a spittin' image of me. Both in physical traits and smartassed hard-headedness. Plus he likes brisket. He asked for leftovers today for lunch, though he did ask for barbeque sauce too... Grrr.
 
Nice job for your first smoke on the WSM. What kind of wood did you use? That is strange that you did not get a smoke ring.

Since the cooking instructions were first published on the virtual weber bullet site, Kingsford has changed their charcoal recipe and I found I don't like it one bit. You might try using the generic HEB charcoal next time to see if that changes the flavor of the meat. Just a thought.

Also, did you put water in the pan in the WSM? I've heard some people use sand covered in foil (for ease of clean-up).
 
Nice work! Sounds like you're figuring out the smoker technique. Did you get a larger water pan, and keep it full?

One thing I noticed is that early on I keep the bottom vents much more closed than on the Virtual Weber Bullet site. Maybe that guy's up north, where it's colder outside. I have one chimney of coals lighted, and then start the vents at ~25% open. It's easy to open them temporarily and raise the temp, but once too many coals are lit, it's hard to cool it down.

BTW, are those pork spare ribs or beef ribs? Maybe it's just the photo, but those look huge for spare ribs.
 
Please explain. Are you saying I have no smoke ring because I trimmed it or that I should have had one especially since I did trim it? I thought it was the wrapping up in foil that inhibited a smoke ring.

I know trimming it was probably a mistake. I'll leave it alone next time, but I'm skeptical that a brisket can taste much better than this one did.

To answer the other questions:
I used pecan wood.
Stock water pan. Only had to refill it twice, but I had it right up to the brim each time.
They were pork spare ribs.
 
I may be wrong but I believe the smoke ring comes from the early part of the smoking thus covering later wouldn't effect that. It probably has more to do with how much wood versus charcoal you use.

I've smoked a steak for 30-60 minutes and gotten smoke rings, its not about the time.
 
Yeah, what Roger said. Honestly, it sounds like you had the steps down pretty well, especially for your first brisket. Seems to be a lack of smoke (not enough wood).

Since we are showing firsts, this was my first brisket. Left it on a bit long and it was falling apart. I smoked this on 100% oak.

IMG_0252.jpg
 
Couple of things-

First off- Congrats- great entry into the world of bbq'ing! You're going to love your pit.

Now that you've mastered your first brisket on the WSM- you may want to get a larger Brinkman pan to replace your water pan. Then you won't have to get up during the night. You'll be able to start your brisket-- make sure it's to temp at about the 1 hour mark-- then go to bed knowing it will stay stable overnight w/o having to refill water/ check on it. WSM will hold temp for 12+ hours- no sweat.

As far as the smoke ring goes- I always understood the ring to be a product of a chemical reaction b/t the smoke and meat- that occurred only until the meat reached a certain temp. I usually use a couple of handfuls of pecan chunks- but, I put the meat on cool (there are different schools of though on this)- fat side up on the WSM top rack (pit is hotter at the dome)- with top vent fully open, and three bottom vents about 1/4 open- with one maybe 1/2 open. usually get a nice smoke ring.

There are other mods you can do- but, get a cheap - $3- academy thermometer (not the more expensive screw in)- and just leave it in the top vent. It will run 10-15 F hotter than the top grate. Always good to have the digital free to check your internal brisket temp (though you will get to where you know the approximate time it will be done- and will be able to tell by feel whether it's ready).

You're already ahead of the curve w/ brisket and ribs. Pork butts and sausage will be childs play- and chickens and turkey will turn out great too.
 
JellyDonuts has a great link for what causes the smoke ring.

This is a picture of my first brisket before and after I cut off the fat cap.

ChiliBrisketWinter2008006.jpg


ChiliBrisketWinter2008007.jpg
 
Good job on the first brisket.

That Weber virtual bullet site has a great recipe for brined, bone-in turkey breasts. I usually do 4 at a time, eat one, and freeze the rest for last consumption.

Also, don't know about the rest of the WSM group, but I have never had much luck with smoking stuff on the bottom rack, other than things like stuffed peppers and throwing some sliced roma tomatoes or smoking some garlic. I've had some OK results, but whatever I put on the middle rack just doesn't seem to get enough heat or smoke (brisket, turkey, chicken).
 
Smoke Ring

This article is the best article that I have ever read on the smoke ring.

Basically you get the smoke ring by:

1) Using curing salt (sodium nitrate) which changes the myoglobin (pigment in the meat) color due to the reaction of the nitrogen and the meat. Think cured meats -- they all have that color of pink. A friend of mine is a serious brisket guy and he told me his secret is to rub the brisket with curing salt and leave it for like 15-30 minutes and then wash it off. Then apply your rub and then throw it on the smoker. He makes the best brisket I know of. Better than my dad, better than my father in law, better than me.... But he has a serious smoker. Some people consider curing salt to be cheating -- I think that it just enhances it b/c I think he would get the ring without it.

2) Smoking with wood at high temperatures in the fire box and for long times in a moist environment. Wood has high concentrations of Nitrogen. Burning wood, creates NO2. Also, you need the moist environment which you can get by using a water pan, which I use, under the brisket. By keeping the brisket moist, you can enhance the ability of the NO2 to get absorbed into the meat to create the smoke ring.
 
Sounds scientific and plausible enough, but I don't use curing salt and I don't use any water in my smoker and I don't brine or marinade my briskets in any way, and still develop a substantial smoke ring.

Not sure what that implies about this theory, but I don't really care either, as long as it tastes good.

smile.gif
 
UTEE, so if you use wood, wood has high levels of nitrogen which in turn if you cook it hot enough creates a crapload of NO2. This absorbs in the brisket to make the smoke ring. Essentially it is the nitrogen in the NO2 (just like the nitrogen in the sodium nitrate salt) that makes the pink ring.

I didn't say you had to use water just that if you use water under your brisket it helps the NO2 from the smoke/wood absorb into the meat.

The article also says that some propane powered cookers if hot enough will have high levels of NO2 and leave a smoke ring too.
 
Sure, I definitely use wood. I have an offset, so it burns at whatever temperature wood burns at in the firebox, and the smoking chamber where the meat is stays near 225 for the duration.
 
Point of argument, some folks state that the water vapors don't get anywhere near close to the stage that would allow the steam to penetrate the meat, thereby rendering the moisture theory moot.

This goes to the idea of a water pan as being for heat dissipation & not much more.

texasflag.gif
hookem.gif
texasflag.gif
hookem.gif
texasflag.gif
 

Weekly Prediction Contest

* Predict HORNS-AGGIES *
Sat, Nov 30 • 6:30 PM on ABC

Recent Threads

Back
Top