Favorite All-Time MLB Players

l00p

10,000+ Posts
I will be honest. I have not followed nor cared much for pro baseball since their last strike many moons ago. I grew up a Dodger fan and had always rooted for them. Followed their Albuquerque Dukes then AAA team and got to watch many players develop and move up and some rehab and go back.

But there are other players I latched on to as well from other teams. I won't list them all but I will list four. Who are yours?

Ron Cey - yup, the Penguin!!! It broke my heart when he went to the Cubs but I never disliked the Cubs so it is not like he betrayed me by playing for the Giants like Garvey did. Bastard! My very favorite player of all time, hands down.

Cal Ripken Jr. - Got to see him play when I lived in D.C. We would road trip or train it up there. Got to see him in the old Stadium and the new Camden Yard. Work ethic and class. I do think he has the only record that won't ever come remotely close to being broken. Nowadays with the high priced athletes, some of which won't play with a hangnail, it is untouchable. This is said over some records but many can be attained in a season or two. This one, over a decade and nobody is even remotely close. Not within YEARS of not missing a game. Amazing.

Fernando Valenzuela - I loved that he could also hit. The hoopla around him was fun. Not necessarily my favorite pitcher nor was he the best, he was just fun. As a kid, that meant a ton.

Ken Griffey Jr. - I could have easily filled this up with Dodgers but this guy, this guy...gives it his all. I remember in his younger days how he would hurl his body up on the wall and make spectacular catches to the detriment of his body sometimes. He did not care, he went to 11. I still wonder where he would be in the chase for records and numbers had he not been hurt so much. A great swing and somebody I always admired amongst the more recent players.

There are more but those came to mind quickly.

Damnit, Pudge, Maddux and a host of others are being left off. Somebody pick these guys for your four.
 
Griffey Jr.
Robbie Alomar
Jim Edmonds
Ozzie Smith
Zambrano
Tori Hunter
Huston Street
Orlando Hudson
Manny
Brandon Phillips


(yeah, I seem to be a defensive minded type-guy when it comes to my favorite MLBers)






Longhorns/NCAA guys:
Brooks Keischnick
Tim Moss
Omar
Dustin
Maroul
Khalil Greene (obviously he's in the MLB but I loved him in college, never get to see him play anymore)
Blake Kelso (current SS/Freshman All-American at U of H)
 
Mickey Mantle
Willie Stargell
harmon killebrew
Al kaline
Carlton Fisk
Thurman Munson
Brooks Robinson
Dave Parker
Catfish Hunter
Johnny Bench
jack Morris
Bernie Williams
lenny Dykstra
By the way 100p I had an ex brother in law that played for Albequrque back in the 60's. His name was jimmy carter. Played there when LaSorda was the manager.
 
Cool. My father would have seen him play as he was in N.M. then. He moved to Houston in the late 60's met my mom. The rest is history. But he did watch them when Tommy was there.

I caught them in the late 70s. Guys like Welch, Maldonado, Sax.
 
Nolan Ryan
Fergie Jenkins
George Brett
Mickey Rivers
Ryne Sandberg
Pedro Martinez
Tim Wakefield
Harold Baines
Robin Yount
Fernando Valenzuela
Rod Carew
 
Henry Aaron
Bob Gibson
Willie Mays
Stan Musial
Ozzie Smith
Yogi Berra
Nolan Ryan
Brooks Robinson
Roberto Clemente
Lou Brock
George Brett
Johnny Bench
Ted Williams

Guess I'm showing my age with those picks...

HHD
hookem.gif
texasflag.gif
coolnana.gif
ousucksnana.gif
 
I saw the beginning of your list and thought it had to be you or maybe ScoPro unless somebody went with players they did not see.

I did get to see Houston Astro games in about 72 but don't remember them.
 
kbrown:

I like your list, but how the heck do you get Muson & Fisk together? That pair was kinda like oil and water.
 
Being a Cardinals fan growing up in the 60/70s, Brock and Gibby were always favorites. Liked the Mad Hungarian and Joaquin Andujar

From other teams:
Hank Aaron
Willie Mays
Willie Stargell
Roberto Clemente
Johnny Bench
Tom Seaver
Jim Palmer
The Alou brothers and the Cruz brothers
Ron Santo (he went to my dad's high school)
Vida Blue although I hated the A's
Same w/ Catfish Hunter
Steve Carlton should be mentioned but it was more grudging that the Cards had traded him for Rick Wise IIRC (don't tell me it was reggie cleveland!)
 
Babe Ruth ("The only real game in the world, I think, is baseball")

Dizzy Dean ("The players take the field at their respectable positions")

Stan Musial (if he'd played in New York...)

Nolan Ryan (loudest pop from a catcher's mitt I've ever heard)

Roy Campanella ("It takes a man to play baseball, but you gotta have a lot of little boy in you, too")

Mickey Mantle ("If i'd known I was going to live this long, I'd have taken better care of myself")

Warren Spahn ("Hitting is timing. Pitching is upsetting timing")

Pee Wee Reese ("Have another Falstaff, Diz")

Bob Gibson ("Get the hell outa here (to Tim McCarver). The only thing you know about pitching is that you can't hit it")

Don Drysdale ("Hey, xxxx, sorry I hit you in the back. I was trying to stick it in your ear!")
 
I too grew up a Dodger fan, so ditto on the Penguin. i can't remember where i parked my truck this morning, but can name you the entire starting lineup from that era, and a few of the backups.

I did not know Garvey went to the Giants, for i remember him becoming a Padre. What forearms. His square-cut jaw always reminded me of my G.I. Joe action figure. However, Garvey's douchebaggery in my 8-year-old mind was complete after the scuffle with Don Sutton in the clubhouse during the world series, of all places. His infomercials after retirement did not help to improve this impression.

Gibson. Enough said.

Willie Stargell. His mother once complimented Vin Scully for being the only media man to call him as she did, by his proper name of "Wilbur" or "Wilver" or something like that.

Rod Carew. I had a Little League coach who, on reflection, probably could have used therapy for the amount of man-love he had for Carew as a hitter.

Rollie Fingers.

Dave effing Winfield. What speed; what an ARM from right. It was only later that i learned that he'd also previously played in Omaha while in college [Minnesota, was it?], which gave him even more points after he was already retired.

Goose Gossage. That guy had the single largest quantity of dip i had ever seen in a human mouth. After a scouting-trip experience with Red Man, that made him very manly in my mind as a boy.

Tony Gwynn. A gentleman, a hitting purist who always had time for the kids. Stayed with his low-dollar team [how about those brown-&-yellow uniforms?] as others must have come calling over the years. Mr. San Diego.

Ditto on Ripken [Jr.].

A thread like this can kill a workday for me.
 
Fied:
<spelling police> Ryne Sandberg <spelling police>

He was named after the old Yankee reliever Ryne Duren.
 
Though he was a Yankee at one time and won 3 or 4 titles with them, Greg Nettles was an amazing defensive 3rd baseman. I remember as a Yankee hater how frustrating it was to watch him snag impossible balls and make the throw to 1st. That or he would stop a ball that there was no way for a human to get to. He sacrificed his body like few others.

Maybe I am getting Steve Garvey confused with somebody else in his going to the VaGiants. I just know he fell out of favor with me.

Fingers and his moustache, awesome.
 
Jim Bouton
Johnny Bench
Rod Carew
Jim Sundberg
Pedro Martinez
Nolan Ryan
Mickey Mantle
Jim Palmer
Brooks Robinson
Ted Williams
 
Garvey was never a Giant, he went to the Padres.

He was one of my all time favorites, always thought he should be in the Hall. His batting numbers didn't quite do it for him.

Others for me that I have seen play:

Bonds
Clemens
Griffey
Bernie Williams
Chet Lemon
Reggie
Bench
Monday
Ozzie G
Big Hurt
Rock
Bo Knows Baseball
Jim Edmunds
 

Weekly Prediction Contest

* Predict HORNS-AGGIES *
Sat, Nov 30 • 6:30 PM on ABC

Recent Threads

Back
Top