ESPN ranking system definitely puts a premium on consistency over exceptional seasons as witnessed by Florida's place on the list. Penders only had 1 losing season that I can remember and then Barnes hasn't had any.
Heck... maybe we are even a top 15 program. I'm not looking at their ranking system... but name 10 programs that have had better results over the last 8 years. That has to count for something.
I have made and will continue to make the argument that this is a top-five program since the arrival of TJ Ford.
The pieces were in place by then (Boddicker, Thomas, Mouton, Ivey), but TJ pushed them to a higher level that Barnes has been able to maintain.
Gibson, Aldridge, Durant and Augustin have come after, along with PJ Tucker. I wouldn't tie it to the names, because my argument is results-driven, but you have to have players, and those guys were the players.