NJlonghorn
2,500+ Posts
I've watched the replay of the Duggan safety multiple times. The clock had just hit 0:01 when Duggan stepped out of bounds. It didn't hit 0 until he was a full 3 steps out of the end zone.
My critique is that Herman should have challenged the call that time had expired. We would've had a chance to try the multi-lateral thing on the ensuing free kick. It probably wouldn't have worked, but why not try?
My rules question is whether the holding penalty would have been enforced on the free kick. I didn't fully understand the ref's explanation, but he seemed to say that 10-yard penalties don't carry over after scoring plays. Is that just for end-of-game scoring plays, or all scoring plays?
My critique is that Herman should have challenged the call that time had expired. We would've had a chance to try the multi-lateral thing on the ensuing free kick. It probably wouldn't have worked, but why not try?
My rules question is whether the holding penalty would have been enforced on the free kick. I didn't fully understand the ref's explanation, but he seemed to say that 10-yard penalties don't carry over after scoring plays. Is that just for end-of-game scoring plays, or all scoring plays?